However, this is where the real questions start – how viable is the material at mass scale, both in terms of sourcing, production and creating products that customers actually prefer to synthetics or higher impact alternatives? Is this making any dent on the vast quantities of plastic textiles H&M produce?
Despite being the product with the lowest percentage of Biofibre (just 11%), a number of the reviews of H&M’s Biofibre hoodie raise questions as to the material’s finish: "Feels like the rough bags rice comes in"..."Kind of a scratchy texture"..."Not crazy about the material"..."Scratchy and uncomfortable." You should consider whether your customers are willing to embrace a more natural-feeling fibre, or alternatively work with Circular Systems to explore BioFibres from alternative crops and/or blends, which may have a softer finish. We believe others are doing a better job - check out Natural Fiber Welding’s Clarus and Mirum for example.
All the finished products featuring Agraloop BioFibre are part of a blended fabric featuring cotton The hoodie and the twill jacket are made in China. While H&M reports that 100% of its cotton is sourced from "sustainable sources," it has faced accusations of supporting forced labor in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region. While the brand has suspended purchasing cotton from the region, it is important for any designer to be aware of similar supply chain risks.
Similar to the point above, while using agricultural waste as a resource for new fibres does, in theory, offer a sustainable option, there needs to be clarity on the processes and sourcing of these fibres. Circular Systems makes some robust claims around Agraloop’s energy and chemical usage, its impact on farming methods and the wider social impact of capturing value from waste. However, you should also review its LCAs and confirm whether they are representative of your specific waste feedstock and sourcing location.
It was reported in 2018 that H&M had USD 4.3 billion worth of unsold stock in warehouses. Aside from highlighting the underlying issues with fast fashion, this huge number also brings about the question as to whether H&M should be focusing on reducing this deadstock, rather than investing energy and resources into new fibre technologies.